Last Friday's disclosure that Rod Beckstrom is resigning from his position as one of the federal government's top cybersecurity executives has exposed widespread - though not universal - opposition to the National Security Agency's expanding role in domestic cybersecurity issues.

Rod Beckstrom resigns as director of National Cybersecurity Center

Many interested parties, including some federal lawmakers, are supporting Beckstrom's contention that allowing an intelligence agency such as the NSA to lead the government's cybersecurity's efforts is a bad idea that will do little to foster the broad collaboration needed to protect public- and private-sector networks against security threats.

Beckstrom, who currently is director of the National Cyber Security Center, said in a sharply worded letter to Janet Napolitano, secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, that he was resigning effective this Friday - less than a year after being appointed to the job at the NCSC. In the letter, he cited concerns about what he described as the NSA's growing domination of national cybersecurity initiatives as the main reason for his decision to quit.

The NCSC was set up within the DHS last year to oversee and coordinate the government's security defenses and responses to cyberthreats. But Beckstrom claimed in his resignation letter that the NSA was effectively running those efforts and is trying to wrest further control away from the DHS by proposing that the offices of both the NCSC and the National Protection and Programs Directorate, another DHS unit, be moved to the intelligence agency's headquarters at Fort George G. Meade in Maryland.

Letting an intelligence agency play the lead role on cybersecurity issues would be "bad strategy on multiple grounds," Beckstrom contended. He wrote that the intelligence culture embodied by the NSA is "very different than a network operations or security culture," and called for "a credible civilian government cybersecurity capability," in which the NSA had a role but not a controlling one.

Similar sentiments were voiced at a hearing on cybersecurity matters held Tuesday by a subcommittee of the U.S. House Committee on Homeland Security. For instance, Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.), the committee's chairman, pointed to Beckstrom's resignation and said it was the result of inefficient leadership, an unclear organizational structure and poorly designed roles and responsibilities within the federal government.

For more enterprise computing news, visit Computerworld. Story copyright Computerworld, Inc.